..


  
  

Review of Manuscript for

Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences

Manuscript number

Reviewer's Name

Reviewer's Number

1. Is the subject matter suitable for the Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences

Yes

No

2. Is the methodology sound? Are the experimental procedures described in sufficient detail?

Yes

No

3. Is the length of the paper appropriate?

Yes

No

4. Are the illustrations and tables clear?

Yes

No

5. Is the bibliography adequate?

Yes

No

6. Are too many references used, or are important references omitted?

Yes

No

7. Overall assessment of manuscript:

a) acceptable without revision

b) acceptable with minor revisions

c) potentially acceptable, but only after major revisions and further review

d) rejection

Confidential comments to the editor (not sent to the author)

COMMENTS BY REVIEWER FOR TRANSMISSION TO AUTHORS

(Opinions on the quality or acceptance of manuscript for publication should not be expressed here)

Manuscript number

Reviewer's Number

Before submitting this form, please print, for your records

 

..

Top of form

© Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences 2001